65 North Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$840,000 Sold Price

Sold on 4/01/2026

3 Beds

3 Baths

1917 SF

Built In 1954

Listing ID	927083



Property Type	House



Township	Shelter Island



Hamlet	Shelter Island

Total Tax	$4,069



Tax ID	0700-014.000-0003-038.000



FEMA Flood Map	fema.gov/portal



Year Built	1954

Associated Documents

	FLOORPLAN	Floor Plan
	DOCUMENT	65-N.Midway-Survey.pdf

Virtual Tour

Shelter Island Retreat

Ideally located near Shelter Island Heights and the Center's amenities, restaurants, shops and library, this charming property offers an excellent opportunity for those seeking an easy-care island retreat or the perfect entry into Shelter Island living. The home features an eat-in kitchen, comfortable and spacious living and family rooms. A primary suite with private bath and a wall of windows overlooking the backyard and pool offering an abundance of light and every-changing scenery. An additional ensuite guest room and a third bedroom with hall bath provide space for family or visitors. Highlights include hardwood floors, propane heat, and central air conditioning. The full unfinished lower level and a second level with expansion potential offer abundant possibilities for added living space or customization. Landscaped for privacy, the fenced backyard includes a pool, storage shed, and a large patio ideal for outdoor dining and entertaining. Just moments from Crescent Beach and the North Ferry.

MORE ▼

Property Details

3 Total Bedrooms
3 Full Baths
1917 SF (AG)
0.43 Acres
Built in 1954
Available 10/25/2025
Ranch Style
Full Basement
Lower Level: Unfinished

Interior Features

Eat-In Kitchen
Oven/Range
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Washer
Dryer
Stainless Steel
Appliance Hot Water Heater
Hardwood Flooring
Furnished
Living Room
Den/Office
Primary Bedroom
en Suite Bathroom
Bonus Room
Kitchen
Laundry
Private Guestroom
First Floor Primary Bedroom
First Floor Bathroom
Forced Air
1 Heat/AC Zones
Propane Fuel
Central A/C

Exterior Features

Frame Construction
Asphalt Shingles Roof
Private Well Water
Private Septic
Pool: In Ground, Vinyl, Heated
Patio
Fence
Shed

Taxes and Fees

$4,069 Total Tax

Sale Information

Sold on 4/01/2026
Sold for $840,000

Previously Listed By

Michael Brennan

Douglas Elliman (Sag Harbor)

Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.

Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent

Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:	I would like more information regarding the East End LI Listing #927083 at 65 North Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY.
Security:	What is 7 plus 1?