5 + Part 3 Hagar Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$2,349,000
Active for Sale
3 Beds
2.5 Baths
3312 SF
Built In 1962
 
Listing ID 921392
Property Type Residential
Township Shelter Island
Hamlet Shelter Island
Total Tax $10,230
Tax ID 0700-018.000-0300-039.000
FEMA Flood Map fema.gov/portal
Year Built 1962
Associated Documents
FLOORPLANFirst Floor
FLOORPLANLower Level
FLOORPLANAll Floors
SURVEYSurvey
 
Virtual Tour

SHELTER ISLAND TURN-KEY WATERFRONT WITH PENINSULA

Set on 1.06 acres with elevated sunrise vistas, this freshly renovated single-story cottage is fully turn-key. The entry foyer, featuring a powder room and separate laundry room, opens to a bright, vaulted main living space that seamlessly combines living and dining areas, featuring a wood-burning fireplace with raised hearth. Strategically placed windows, including a striking round accent window near the ceiling, perfectly frame captivating views of blue sky and water. Glass doors open to an expansive 1,109 +/- sq. ft. water-view deck spanning the center of the rear of the home. The well-appointed kitchen, complete with a breakfast island and service area, is designed for effortless entertaining. The northern wing offers two guest bedrooms with water views, and a spa-like shared bathroom featuring double sinks, a soaking tub, and a separate shower. The spacious ensuite primary includes two walk-in closets and a luxurious bath with a steam shower, double sinks, and a private commode room. On the southern side, a library with custom built-ins and water views offers a quiet retreat, with adjacent attached two-car garage and a staircase to the lower level. The partially above-grade basement provides storage and easy outdoor access, along with a generator hook-up for added peace of mind. Down the hill lies a rare offering: half ownership of a serene waterfront peninsula, a natural buffer between the home and shoreline. Meandering footpaths wind through this private sanctuary, where long-legged wading birds, tree toads, crabs, and diamondback terrapins have been seen - a perfect setting for nature lovers and quiet reflection. For boaters, the property is near open waters and a boatyard with recreational amenities. Taxes for Part 3 Hagar Rd: $674.05. Taxes for 5 Hagar Rd: $6623.25
Property Details
  • 3 Total Bedrooms
  • 2 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 3312 SF (AG)
  • 3312 SF (Total)
  • 1.06 Acres
  • Built in 1962
  • Renovated 2012
  • Contemporary Style
  • Full Basement
  • Lower Level: Unfinished, Walk Out
  • Renovation: Wired for generator/ADT-thermostats/lights remote, propane, Trex deck, mahogany deck, boiler. 50% ownership of 3 Hagar is included.
Interior Features
  • Pass-Through Kitchen
  • Granite Kitchen Counter
  • Oven/Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Microwave
  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Stainless Steel
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Entry Foyer
  • Living Room
  • Dining Room
  • Family Room
  • Primary Bedroom
  • en Suite Bathroom
  • Walk-in Closet
  • Bonus Room
  • Great Room
  • Kitchen
  • Breakfast
  • Private Guestroom
  • First Floor Primary Bedroom
  • First Floor Bathroom
  • 1 Fireplace
  • Alarm System
  • Hot Water
  • Oil Fuel
  • Central A/C
Exterior Features
  • Frame Construction
  • Hardi-Board Siding
  • Masonry Siding
  • Asphalt Shingles Roof
  • Attached Garage
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • Private Well Water
  • Private Septic
  • Deck
  • Covered Porch
  • Driveway
  • Survey
  • Subdivision: Menantic Colony
  • Creek View
  • Wooded View
  • Scenic View
  • Creek Waterfront
Taxes and Fees
  • $10,230 County Tax
  • $10,230 Total Tax
  • Tax Year 2025
Listed By
Saunders & Associates
Office: 631-749-5801
Mobile: 917-208-5519
Request More Information
Request Showing
Role Agent Buyer
Your Preferred Date & Time
Showing Type:
Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.
Contact Us
Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent
Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:
Security: What is 8 minus 5?